At dusk on January 10, 2005 the Chairman of the Bassa
Concern Citizen Movement, a 12 year old grass-roots
and people organization based in Grand Bassa County
requested the intervention of Liberian human rights
and pro-democracy organizations in the illegal arrest
and detention of more than 80 persons. Mr. Gabriel
Smith indicated that 88 persons from District No 4
in Grand Bassa County had been arrested including
a ten year old boy called Shadrach Banwon. He also
pointed out that the arrest took place as local people
tried to protest their eviction from their ancestral
homeland. During the arrest, carried out by police
officers who were apparently dispatched from Monrovia,
the protesters were manhandled and had personal belongings
including cash and wrist watches were extorted by
those who had come to arrest them. Mr. Gabriel Smith
narrated this incident to Attorney Alfred Brownell,
Executive Director of Green Advocate. Mr. Brownell
immediately called his colleagues including Atty Samuel
Kofi Woods, II (FIND), Counselor James Verdier (LDW)
and Ezekiel Pajibo (CEDE). The four Human Rights and
Pro-democracy Advocates immediately to Buchanan to
obtain further information.
Upon arrival in Buchanan on January 11, 2005, the
delegation headed for the Buchanan Police station,
where the detainees were held. The appalling condition
under which the detainees were held was easily established.
Eleven of the detainees, who were said to be juvenile
were held on the first floor of the Police Station
without shirts and sitting on the bare floor. They
appeared to be clearly hungry, thirsty and dirty.
They had not been fed by the authorities since their
detention on Monday evening at about 6:00 P.M. The
majority of the prisoners were held just before the
police station surrounded by barbwires on three side
and the front wall of the police station on the fourth
side. They looked caged, bewildered, frustrated, deeply
humiliated and abusively denigrated by public servants
working on behalf of the National Transitional Government
of Liberia. There is no doubt in our mind that the
pitiable conditions of the detainees constituted torture,
cruel, inhumane and degrading treatment. We are abhorred
that our people could be held in such despicable,
horrendous and unacceptable condition and forcefully
condemn this blatant and irresponsible abuse of human
rights by Government Authorities who should be securing,
upholding and protecting the rights of every and all
Liberians.
We proceeded to meet the relevant authority to seek
further information on the state of the detainee and
the condition for the arrest and detention. We were
told by an UNMIL Civil Police Officer, Rannie Vick
that the local Chief of Police was upstairs. When
we approached the information desk which is about
7 feet away from the position where we informed that
the Chief of Police was upstairs in the building,
we were informed by a civil servant, apparently the
Receptionist that "The chief was here all day
today he just left to go and get something to eat."
Where was he having his lunch was unknown to all of
the public servants present at the Buchanan Police
Station. We requested to see the Deputy Chief, he
too had surreptitiously vanished into thin air. Not
a single person in the Buchanan Police Station around
3:00 P.M. on January 11, would say where the Deputy
Chief of Police had gone.
Our next port of call was to meet with the County
Attorney, Mr. Richard Davies in his office. Mr. Davies
told our delegation that he had heard the "news
on the air" while in Monrovia. He traveled to
Buchanan on January 11 and that up to the time we
met with him, the Police had not brought any case
to him and he was not in the position to address our
concern.
We asked for the local Judge and we were told that
he had gone home. We found a dutiful Liberian citizen
who knew the house of the Judge and took us to his
house. When we got there we were told that the Judge
had gone to work and had not yet returned home. All
this time, we were attempting to meet local authorities
to provide us with the information about the detainees
and pursue the necessary legal redress applicable
under the circumstances. More importantly we were
trying to seek the immediate release of the detainees
in the absence of any charges against them and relieve
them from the abhorrent conditions under which they
were being held.
Upon returning to the Police Station, the Deputy Police
Chief fortunately reappeared. Before meeting with
the Deputy Chief, we proceeded to meet with the Magistrate
to acquire legal means to have the detainees released.
The Magistrate pointed to the clock on the wall and
said that it was almost time for him to go home. However,
he may consider doing what we wanted if we would be
responsible for his "over time". During
negotiation with the Magistrate, another civil servant
believed to be the Messenger and referred to as "Bryant"
appeared and whispered into the… ear of the
Magistrate who subsequently appeared visibly confused.
He got up from his seat and followed Messenger Bryant
out of the office. While walking out he shouted at
us that he was going "talk to my people".
He returned and sheepishly informed us that this was
beyond his power. He reasoned that he did not have
the "power to tell the Deputy Commander what
to do".
We then met with Deputy Commander, Wesseh Bloh-Jay.
After intense discussion and negotiation with Deputy
Commander, we convinced him about the illegality of
the arrest, the deplorable conditions under which
the detainees were being kept and the likelihood of
increased tension if the detainees were not released.
We pointed to him that just outside his window was
an increasingly menacing crowd that did not need additional
reason to behave in any disorderly action or take
other measures that would create difficulty in the
City. The Deputy Commander agreed and a surety bond
was signed with all the detainees except three persons
were released. The three who were not released were
said to be the "ringleaders". In actual
fact they include the following: J. Barkon Nyannahkpe,
Steven Gbarginggar and Johnson Moses, who are actually
community and traditional leaders within the Number
4 District of Grand Bassa County.
This morning, January 12, 2005, Counselor Verdier
and Attorney Brownell departed Monrovia to represent
the detainees before the Court. The human rights advocate
will essentially seek to hear charges against the
detainee, obtain bonds, if charges are levied and
or proceed to seek their permanent release, once charges
cannot be adduced. In addition, the various organizations
including, Liberia Democracy Watch, Green Advocate,
Foundation for Human Rights and Democracy, Foundation
for International Dignity and the Center for Democratic
Empowerment, are considering to expand on its complaints
before the Court related to the forceful eviction
of persons from their ancestral homeland by the Liberia
Agricultural Corporation in cahoots with the Liberian
Government, seek compensation for the destruction
of properties including homes and crops by the Liberia
Agricultural Company.
More importantly, the various organizations will seek
to expand public debate on questions of Land Reform,
the misbehavior of corporations in our country, and
the questions related to resource management in Liberia.
Thanks for your appearance and we will now take a
few questions.
Samuel Kofi Woods II (FIND)
Ezekiel Pajibo (CEDE)
Jerome Verdier (LDW)
Alfred Brownell (Green Advocates)